Anglican Church ‘misleading’ SA on Israel, says SA Friends of Israel

Leader of the Anglican Church of Southern Africa Archbishop Thabo Makgoba, left and chief spokesman of South Africa Friends of Israel Bafana Modise

A decision by the Anglican Church of Southern Africa (ACSA) to declare Israel an apartheid state “is highly concerning” as it “portrays a false view of the conflict between the Palestinians and Israel,” says Bafana Modise, head of communications at South African Friends of Israel (SAFI).

In the resolution passed by the Provincial Standing Committee of ACSA last Thursday, the church noted that its decision aligned it with human rights bodies such at Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch, the national executive committee of the South African Council of Churches, the Dutch Reformed Church Western Cape synod and “most Palestinian civil rights bodies”.

In a blog statement on the resolution ACSA leader Archbishop Thabo Makgoba says: “When black South Africans who have lived under apartheid visit Israel, the parallels to apartheid are impossible to ignore. If we stand by and keep quiet, we will be complicit in the continuing oppression of the Palestinians.

Modise points out that in a recent interview with SAFI, former SA defence minister Mosiuoa Lekota who has visited Israel, debunked the “apartheid Israel” label, saying that “in Israel, you won’t find the same divisions between Jews and non-Jews that we used to witness during apartheid”.

“To disseminate this narrative in South Africa only serves to expropriate the suffering of black people under apartheid, in a manner that serves the interests and agenda of a very antisemitic international organisation, the Boycott, Divest, Sanctions Movement (BDS),” he says.

Modise’s statement also criticises ACSA for not engaging with SAFI regarding its decision. He says:
This is concerning as SAFI is a well established member of a number of church-based organisations across South Africa. In fact, SAFI has received a number of appeals from members of the Anglican church that remain outraged at the decision taken yesterday.

Out of touch with members’ views
“James van den Heever, has written a thesis on this topic within the Anglican Church, indicating that repeated attempts by members to contact the Church leadership on the subject have been ignored for a number of years. This tells us that the views of the Church leadership do not reflect those of its members — the majority of South Africans love the Holy Land of Israel and would rather play a productive role in ending the conflict, as opposed to recycling the views of antisemitic organisations like the BDS movement,” says Modise.

He says SAFI plans to meet with a number of churches in SA over the next few months to formally oppose ACSA’s decision to declare Israel an apartheid state. During the meetings they will provide Anglican Church members and other Christians with “a more educated view of why the conflict remains between the Palestinians and Israel today”.

He says SAFI will also “continue to support individuals within the Anglican Church in their efforts to share that this decision in no way represents the views of the majority of Anglicans in South Africa”.


Subscribe to our weekly newsletter
Help us publish news that brings hope in Jesus: Donate / Become a Super Subscriber

Visit our Advertising Noticeboard
for Christian events, and more


You are welcome to engage with our articles by making comments [in the Comments area below] that add value to a topic or to engage in thoughtful, constructive discussion with fellow readers. Comments that contain vulgar language will be removed. Hostile, demeaning, disrespectful, propagandistic comments may also be moved. This is a Christian website and if you wish to vent against Christian beliefs you have probably come to the wrong place and your comments may be removed. Ongoing debates and repetitiveness will not be tolerated. You will also disqualify yourself from commenting if you engage in trolling.

Click on banner for more info


  1. It is an insult to black folk to compare israel and the apartheid system of south africa. The walls built in israel is meant to protect innocent folk from genocide. Apartheid in south africa was meant to advance white privaledge.

  2. This is no surprise. The Anglican Church became a wordly entity a long time ago. Its really bizarre but hey, anything fed by the devil has no logic

  3. I’m encouraged that SAFI is taking action. The Bishops are completely out of touch with Anglicans. Praying that our Bishops see the light and be set free by the truth.

  4. Dennis Neville Stirk

    I cannot be seen to be supporting Main Line Churches in SA. Because of government affiliations, most support BDI ( Boycott and Disinvestment in Israel). I sympathize with those in ministry who are against such a stance, but rely on the church for future living. This ANC government has proved itself incapable of a positive future starting NOW. ITS-TIME for them to disappear if we are to survive. The Jewish People ( GOD’s Chosen Race whether the secular world likes it or not) haven tried their very best to help and support their Arab brothers. The Jews are maligned and goaded by the UN and others at every opportunity